Support Groups vs. Therapy Groups: What's the Difference and Why It Matters
Which One is Right for You?
“You are not alone on this journey, lean on your tribe, and let them lift you up when you need them the most”
Anonymous
When looking for support for emotional well-being, people frequently weigh the choice between therapy groups and support groups. Although both offer significant advantages, they have different objectives and organizational structures.
The key difference between therapy groups and support groups is that therapy groups are led by a trained professional who offers therapeutic interventions, insights, and coping strategies grounded in psychological principles. Support groups are gatherings of individuals who share common challenges and offer mutual help and understanding.
Both types of groups provide emotional support and empathy, advice on coping mechanisms and tools, as well as an opportunity to build accountability for one’s actions, behaviors, and efforts toward healing. They help reduce feelings of isolation and loneliness and can assist individuals in overcoming feelings of stigma and resistance. However, let’s examine each type more closely
Support groups
Support groups are gatherings of people united by common struggles, typically concerning addiction, mental health, or personal challenges. They create a safe and encouraging space for participants to share experiences, offer support, and better understand each other's paths. The power of support groups is rooted in the community they foster and the connection formed through shared challenges, which alleviates feelings of loneliness and fosters a sense of belonging empathy.
Support groups come in various forms to meet diverse needs. Some meet in person, allowing individuals to gather face-to-face, foster personal connections, and enable physical presence with others who share similar challenges. Alternatively, online support groups offer flexibility, anonymity, and easy access to resources from the comfort of home, making them ideal for individuals in remote locations or those who prefer digital interaction.
Well-known support groups include 12-step programs like Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) and Narcotics Anonymous (NA). These groups guide members through 12 steps focused on admitting powerlessness over addiction, seeking spiritual guidance, and making amends. The model emphasizes community, enabling individuals to share progress and challenges, forming a supportive network throughout recovery.
Non-12-step groups offer alternative recovery methods. Programs like SMART Recovery and Secular Organizations for Sobriety (SOS) focus on self-empowerment, cognitive-behavioral techniques, and practical skills, allowing individuals to manage their recovery without relying on spiritual elements or 12-step principles. These groups appeal to those seeking a secular or scientific approach to addiction recovery.
Pros and Cons of Support Groups
Participants can connect with others who understand what they are going through. This shared experience can provide comfort and reduce feelings of isolation.
Support groups often foster a sense of belonging, and members can offer emotional support to each other. These connections can significantly enhance individual well-being and promote resilience during challenging times.
Support groups are typically free or low-cost in comparison to therapy.
They offer opportunities for volunteering and leadership activities. Being able to help others through their struggles can foster a sense of empowerment and self-worth.
Cons
Although peer support is beneficial, support groups might not have the expertise or direction of a licensed therapist or coach, potentially resulting in less productive conversations.
Members may provide guidance rooted in personal experience instead of professional expertise, potentially leading to harmful or inaccurate outcomes.
Support groups may not adhere to the same confidentiality rules as therapy, raising potential privacy issues.
Support groups often center around common experiences and emotional support; however, they should not explore specific therapeutic interventions.
In certain instances, the dynamics of a group or the behavior of specific individuals within the group may inadvertently promote negative thought patterns or behaviors.
“People who wonder if the glass is half empty or half full miss the point. The glass is refillable.”
Simon Sinek
Therapy groups
A therapy group is a structured and guided environment where individuals come together to address personal challenges with the support of a trained mental health professional. These groups are led by licensed experts, such as therapists, counselors, or psychologists, who possess the knowledge and expertise to provide therapeutic interventions tailored to the specific needs of the group. The diversity of the participants can often enhance the experience, as individuals share unique perspectives and strategies, fostering an inclusive atmosphere of support and understanding.
Sessions are typically held on a regular basis, whether weekly or bi-weekly, and follow a specific framework designed to promote healing, growth, and personal development. This framework may include various therapeutic techniques, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), mindfulness practice, or group discussions, aimed at helping members process their emotions and experiences.
In therapy groups, participants are encouraged to openly discuss their individual struggles, which not only facilitates personal insight but also builds connections with others who are facing similar issues. Sharing experiences can lessen feelings of isolation, allowing members to realize that they are not alone in their challenges. Additionally, the validation and encouragement received from peers and the therapist can significantly boost one’s self-esteem and motivation, leading to more profound personal transformations.
Therapy groups typically focus on therapeutic techniques such as cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), mindfulness, or interpersonal therapy, depending on the group's focus. They provide a safe, confidential space for participants to explore their feelings, behaviors, and thoughts, while the therapist helps guide the conversation and ensures the group remains productive and supportive.
Some common types of therapy groups include:
Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) groups: Focus on assisting individuals in recognizing and altering unhelpful thought patterns and behaviors that affect their well-being, employing a structured, problem-oriented approach to tackle current challenges and cultivate coping skills.
Trauma-focused therapy groups: Designed for individuals who have experienced trauma or abuse. They aim to ensure a safe and supportive environment for survivors to share their experiences, learn coping skills, and process trauma-related emotions and thoughts.
Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT) groups: Focus on emotional regulation and mindfulness techniques. mindfulness, distress tolerance, emotion regulation, and interpersonal effectiveness. These skills aim to assist individuals in managing intense emotions, enhancing relationships, and coping with difficulties.
Supportive therapy groups: There are many other types of therapy groups that can address specific issues, each catering to the differing needs and therapeutic goals of the participants..
Overall, therapy groups can serve as a powerful tool for emotional healing and growth, providing a safe space where individuals can explore their thoughts and feelings, learn from one another, and develop healthier coping mechanisms together.
Pros and Cons of Therapeutic Groups
Pros:
A therapist-led group can navigate difficult conversations and group dynamics, emphasizing the importance of respect, open-mindedness, and setting boundaries within support groups.
A licensed therapist offers professional guidance, assisting the group in tackling issues in an organized and constructive manner, often achieving positive outcomes much quicker than support groups.
Therapy groups can introduce specific strategies and skills, like cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), mindfulness, or problem-solving techniques.
Confidentiality: Therapy groups operate under strict professional confidentiality, guaranteeing that information shared within the group remains private
Therapy groups can enhance personal growth by emphasizing both group dynamics and individual therapeutic progress at the same time, offering opportunities for further insight and understanding.
Safe Environment: The organized format of therapy groups can provide individuals with a greater sense of security when discussing sensitive topics.
Cons:
Therapy groups often come with a cost, and while they are generally less expensive than individual therapy, they can still pose a barrier for some people.
Group Size: Depending on the group, it may be challenging to receive individual attention or to speak up in a larger setting.
Group dynamics: At times, the dynamics within therapy groups can be difficult, particularly if specific individuals dominate the conversation or if conflicts arise within the group.
Therapy groups may have structured meeting schedules and requirements, which can be challenging for some individuals to commit to.
“Tough love and brutal truth from strangers are far more valuable than band-aids and half-truths from invested friends.”
- Shannon L. Alder
Questions to ask yourself to determine which is right for you
Have self-help support groups not helped you achieve your interpersonal goals in the past? What is my current level of functioning?
Are you looking to dive deeper into personal mental health issues?
Do you feel you need professional guidance to work through trauma or behavioral patterns, or are you seeking structured therapeutic interventions?
Do you have persistent feelings of sadness or depression? If you have been feeling sad, empty, or hopeless for an extended period (weeks or months), it may be a sign of depression. This is especially true if these feelings interfere with daily functioning, such as work, school, or relationships.
Do you experience excessive anxiety or worry that interferes with your daily functioning?
Do you have a history of past trauma or abuse?
Do you have physical symptoms with no observable medical cause?
Are you seeking a community of people with similar experiences to offer emotional support, advice, and shared coping strategies?
Are you seeking a less formal setting and prioritizing having a space for belonging and mutual understanding?
Questions to ask when exploring group options:
What are my personal preferences, needs, and goals?
What is the group’s philosophy?
How do they handle new members?
What is the group dynamic like?
Does the group’s core identity align with your specific recovery goals (substance-specific groups, general addiction support, gender-specific groups, etc.)?
Is there homework assigned?
What happens if I miss a session?
Are the meetings offered at a time that works within my schedule?
What are the group leaders’ experiences and credentials?
Will I be referred for additional help if I need it?
In summary,
Ultimately, the choice between a support group and a therapeutic group hinges on your personal goals, the type of assistance you seek, and your comfort level with the format. But I cannot stress enough the importance of finding a group that aligns with your specific recovery goals.
Regardless of the path you choose, both can offer meaningful support in your journey toward healing and growth, and at times, a combination of the two can be the most advantageous.
I hope you find this information helpful. However, I must also mention that the advice given is for informational purposes only. It is not intended to diagnose or treat any condition. I always recommend that you consult with a licensed professional in their field of expertise.
If you believe this article will benefit someone else, please share it and email me if you have a topic you would like me to address. The email address is linked above.
If you found this topic interesting, you may want to explore one of the following options…
Resources
Group Therapy https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK549812/
“Rebuilding Relationships in Recovery: How to Connect with Family and Close Friends After Active Alcoholism and Addiction” by Janice V. Johnson Dowd, LMSW, 2025, North Atlantic Books Publishing